Mental Health Act
The Mental Health Act refers to legislation that governs how people with mental health challenges can be assessed, treated, and protected. While specific provisions vary by country, state, and jurisdiction, most Mental Health Acts typically share common elements.
Key features generally include:
- Involuntary admission/commitment: Criteria and procedures for when someone can be detained for assessment or treatment without their consent
- Rights protection: Safeguards for patients including right to appeal, independent review, and access to advocacy
- Treatment authorization: Rules about when treatment can be given without consent
- Community treatment orders: Provisions for supervised treatment in the community
- Nearest relative/guardian provisions: Rights of family members or designated representatives
- Professional roles: Defining who can make assessments and decisions (psychiatrists, mental health officers, etc.)
Mental Health Acts aim to balance:
- Individual liberty and autonomy
- Need for treatment
- Public safety concerns
- Protection of vulnerable individuals
These laws typically include special provisions for:
- Emergency situations
- Children and young people
- Individuals with intellectual disabilities
- Criminal justice interactions
Mental Health Acts are regularly reviewed and updated to reflect evolving understanding of mental health, human rights standards, and best practices in care. The implementation varies significantly between different countries and regions, with different terminology and specific procedures.
What is a Mental Health Act in Australia?
Rather than having a single national Mental Health Act, each state and territory has its own legislation that reflects local approaches while adhering to national principles and international human rights standards.
These acts establish the legal basis for voluntary and involuntary assessment, treatment, and care of people experiencing serious mental illness, with a focus on using the least restrictive options and promoting recovery.
Individual state and territory Mental Health Acts
- Victoria: Mental Health and Wellbeing Act 2022 (replacing the Mental Health Act 2014)
- New South Wales: Mental Health Act 2007
- Queensland: Mental Health Act 2016
- Western Australia: Mental Health Act 2014
- South Australia: Mental Health Act 2009
- Tasmania: Mental Health Act 2013
- Australian Capital Territory: Mental Health Act 2015
- Northern Territory: Mental Health and Related Services Act 1998
Key principles across Australian Mental Health Acts
Despite variations, all Australian Mental Health Acts embody core principles:
- Least restrictive treatment: Using the minimum intervention necessary
- Supported decision-making: Enabling patients to participate in treatment decisions
- Recovery-oriented practice: Focusing on rehabilitation and social inclusion
- Rights protection: Safeguarding the human rights of people with mental illness
- Dignity and respect: Treating patients with consideration for their individual needs
- Qualified practitioners: Ensuring only authorised health professionals can make certain decisions
- Accountability and review: Establishing mechanisms to challenge treatment decisions
- Family and carer involvement: Recognising the role of support networks while respecting privacy
Involuntary treatment provisions
All Australian Mental Health Acts include criteria for involuntary treatment, typically requiring:
- Presence of mental illness: The person must have a diagnosed mental illness or disorder
- Risk criteria: The person must present a risk to themselves or others
- Treatment availability: Appropriate treatment must be available and likely to be beneficial
- Capacity consideration: The person’s capacity to make treatment decisions is compromised
- Least restrictive alternative: No less restrictive means of treatment is reasonably available
Types of orders under Mental Health Acts
- Assessment orders: Short-term orders enabling examination of a person’s mental state
- Treatment orders: Authorising treatment for a specified period
- Community treatment orders: Allowing involuntary treatment while living in the community
- Inpatient treatment orders: Requiring treatment within a mental health facility
- Transport orders: Authorising transportation of a person to a facility for assessment
- Security orders: Special provisions for forensic patients (those in the criminal justice system)
Patient rights under Mental Health Acts
Australian Mental Health Acts establish various rights, including:
- Right to information: About diagnosis, treatment options, and legal status
- Right to communicate: With legal representatives, family, and official visitors
- Right to second opinions: Access to alternative medical assessments
- Right to review: Appeal mechanisms through mental health tribunals or courts
- Right to make advance statements: Documenting treatment preferences when well
- Right to nominate a support person: Appointing someone to assist with decisions
- Right to dignity and respect: Being treated humanely and with cultural sensitivity
- Right to the least restrictive treatment: Having freedom restricted only as necessary
Key authorities and oversight bodies
- Mental Health Tribunals/Review Boards: Independent bodies that review involuntary treatment orders
- Chief Psychiatrists: Statutory officers responsible for clinical standards and oversight
- Official Visitors/Advocates: Independent visitors who monitor facilities and handle complaints
- Public Guardians: May be appointed to make decisions for those without capacity
- Health Complaints Commissioners: Handle complaints about health services
- Community Visitors Programs: Conduct inspections of mental health facilities
Mental Health Act and the workplace
The Mental Health Acts have implications for employers and employees:
- Disclosure requirements: Balancing privacy with workplace safety considerations
- Reasonable adjustments: Obligations under disability discrimination legislation
- Return to work planning: For employees recovering from mental illness
- Confidentiality: Protecting the privacy of employees’ health information
- Certification of absence: Requirements for medical certificates related to mental health
- Unfair dismissal protections: Safeguards against discrimination
Interaction with other legislation
Mental Health Acts operate alongside other relevant legislation:
- Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Commonwealth)
- Guardianship Acts (state/territory specific)
- Criminal Law/Forensic Mental Health provisions
- Privacy legislation
- Carers Recognition Acts
- National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013
- Advance Care Directives legislation
Recent reforms and trends
Mental health legislation in Australia has undergone significant evolution:
- Human rights focus: Greater emphasis on rights protection and autonomy
- Recovery orientation: Shift from custodial to recovery-based approaches
- Supported decision-making: Moving away from substituted decision-making
- Trauma-informed care: Recognising the impact of trauma on mental health
- Cultural considerations: Increasing recognition of culturally appropriate care
- Carer and family inclusion: Greater recognition of support persons’ roles
- Reduced seclusion and restraint: Minimising restrictive practices
- Enhanced oversight: Strengthened monitoring and complaint mechanisms
Mental Health Act and aboriginal and torres strait islander peoples
Specific considerations for Indigenous Australians include:
- Cultural safety requirements: Ensuring culturally appropriate service delivery
- Aboriginal Liaison Officers: Specialised roles to support Indigenous patients
- Cultural assessment: Consideration of cultural factors in assessment process
- Community connections: Maintaining links with community and country
- Cultural healing practices: Recognition of traditional healing approaches
- Intergenerational trauma: Acknowledging historical contexts affecting mental health
- Family and kinship: Recognition of broader family structures and responsibilities
Practical applications for consumers and carers
Understanding Mental Health Acts helps individuals navigate the system:
- Knowing your rights: Resources for patients to understand their entitlements
- Advocacy support: Services available to assist during tribunal hearings
- Making advance statements: How to document treatment preferences
- Nominating support persons: Processes for formal nomination
- Complaint mechanisms: How to raise concerns about treatment
- Second opinion processes: Steps to obtain alternative medical views
- Consent and capacity: Understanding when treatment can be given without consent
Challenges and criticisms
Australian Mental Health Acts face several ongoing challenges:
- Balancing rights and treatment: Tension between autonomy and therapeutic needs
- Implementation gaps: Difference between legislative intent and practical application
- Resource limitations: Inadequate services limiting least restrictive options
- Geographic disparities: Rural and remote access challenges
- Consistency issues: Variations in interpretation and application
- Cultural appropriateness: Adapting practices for diverse communities
- Stigma and discrimination: Ongoing prejudice despite legislative protections
- Forensic mental health: Complex intersection with criminal justice system
Prioritise Your Team’s Wellbeing
Book a consultation with our experts and discuss your team’s wellness needs.